Sign inOpen the app
IP Lex · Indian IP case law

IP Case Law › Trade Marks › American Home Products Corporation v. Mac Laboratories Priva…

Trade Marks Ragulika IP case note

American Home Products Corporation v. Mac Laboratories Private Limited & Anr.

CourtSupreme Court of India
BenchHon'ble Justice D.P. Madon and Hon'ble Justice Amarendra Nath Sen
Case numberCivil Appeal (1985)
CitationAIR 1986 SC 137
Judgment date30 September 1985
IP categoryTrade Marks
PartiesAmerican Home Products Corporation (Appellant) v. Mac Laboratories Private Limited & Anr. (Respondents)

Relevant Acts and provisions

Provisions considered: Sections 18, 46 and 48, Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958

Brief facts

Mac Laboratories applied to rectify the register by removing the appellant's mark for non-use. The Registrar of Trade Marks, Calcutta dismissed the application, but a Single Judge of the Calcutta High Court allowed the respondent's appeal.

Issues before the Court

Whether the appellant's registration, obtained on the basis of proposed use through an Indian registered user, was liable to be removed.

Court's findings

The Court reversed the Single Judge and upheld the Registrar's dismissal of the rectification application.

Decision

Appeal allowed; the respondent's appeal before the Single Judge dismissed with costs and the Registrar's order confirmed; costs of the appeal to the appellant.

Key legal principle / ratio

A proprietor may validly register a mark proposed to be used through a registered user, and such a registration is not liable to removal for non-use merely because the proprietor itself has not used the mark.

Important paragraph references

Concluding paragraph: disposal. Read the judgment for the detailed discussion of Sections 18, 46 and 48.

Important: This case note is a research summary only. It must be verified against the full judgment by a qualified lawyer, advocate or patent/trade mark attorney before any reliance. Do not rely on it as legal advice; Ragulika IP accepts no responsibility for its accuracy or for any action taken on it.

Keywords

Foreign Proprietor Non-use Proposed Use Rectification Registered User

Read the judgment

View judgment (court website)