IP Case Law › Patents › K.K. Bansal v. Koninklijke Philips Electronics N.V.
Relevant Acts and provisions
Patents Act, 1970
Provisions considered: Section 107A(b)
Brief facts
Philips sued the Bansals, who assembled and sold DVD players, for infringement of a patent relating to DVD technology. By a judgment dated 12 July 2018, a Single Judge decreed the suits, awarding FRAND-based royalty damages and punitive damages. The Bansals filed regular first appeals, which were heard together.
Free to read once you are signed in
Read the rest of this case note
The findings, the decision and the principle the court settled on are below. Create a free account to keep reading. No payment, and nothing to cancel.
Already have an account? Sign in
We use your details to give you access and to contact you about your enquiry. See our privacy policy.
Keywords
Damages FRAND Patent Exhaustion Patent Infringement Punitive Damages Royalty Base Standard Essential Patent
Read the judgment
More Patents judgments
Patents
Agriboard International LLC v. Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs
An order refusing a patent for lack of inventive step must contain a reasoned analysis of the prior art and of why the claimed invention would be obvious; an unreasoned order will be set aside and remanded.
Inventive StepPatent OfficePrior Art AnalysisReasoned OrderPatentsArray Biopharma Inc v. Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs
A combination of distinct and independent active drugs, each with its own chemical identity and mechanism, does not fall under the Section 3(d) bar for derivatives of known substances. Using phrases such as 'for simultaneous, sepa…
Inventive StepMethod of TreatmentPharmaceutical CombinationPrior ArtPatentsAstraZeneca AB & Anr. v. Intas Pharmaceuticals Limited
A patentee that has treated a later patent as coextensive in term with an earlier patent covering the same compound abroad cannot, at the interim stage, claim a longer period of protection for the later patent in India; interim re…
DapagliflozinEvergreeningGenus PatentInterim Injunction